Symphony No. 2, OP. 24
Robert Whitney, conductor
Louisville Orchestra First Edition Records — LP LOU-616
III. Presto gioioso
“There is a degree of freshness and impetuosity that defines Kurka as an imitator of nobody. It must stand as the insufficient summation of a talent that was only beginning to find itself when Kurka died in the fall of 1957.” Thus read the Saturday Review’s critique of the 1959 Carnegie Hall premiere of Robert Kurka’s Second Symphony.
Symphony No. 2 was written on a commission Kurka received in 1952 from the Paderewski Fund for the Encouragement of American Composers. It premiered on 9 July 1958 with the San Diego Symphony under the direction of John Barnett. The San Diego Evening Tribune reported, “It swells with the teeming rush of the metropolis. Kurka’s symphony is mindful of the best traditions of 19th-century music.” Performances by the Cleveland Orchestra and the Boston Symphony soon followed, both conducted by Robert Shaw. The Boston Symphony performed it at home, and at Carnegie Hall in 1959. The Boston Herald reported it as being “A work of immense vitality and color … combines American optimism and bustle with Slavic rhetoric.” Of the Carnegie Hall premiere the New Yorker said, “A composition of great individuality … has a sureness of draftsmanship that is not often encountered in contemporary American symphonies.” Musical America commented, “It is a shame that it had to wait so long for a performance, for it is worthy of not one but repeated hearings … extremely fresh and appealing.”
I first performed the Second Symphony with the Indianapolis Symphony in 1972. On first hearing, it sounded a bit like Americanized Prokofiev, with a touch of the quirkiness of Kurt Weill. And then, thirty years later, I located the widow of Robert Kurka and spent a week with her. I explored and copied two filing cabinets filled with his original scores, his letters, his photos, and an astounding number of premiere recordings of his works, many of which were on paper-backed, magnetized reels. I had them transferred to CDs. But that is all a tale for yet another day…