Blog > Musical Giants of the 20th Century: Pianists
by Frances Wilson | July 31st, 2016

standard Musical Giants of the 20th Century: Pianists

Marguerite LongCredit: http://bn.org.pl/

Marguerite Long
Credit: http://bn.org.pl/

Narrowing a list of “great pianists” down to 10 was not an easy task – there are so many who merit inclusion! And readers will inevitably have their own personal list of pianistic heroes and heroines. But I hope this selection will demonstrate the special qualities of each pianist chosen and their contribution to the world of piano and the wider worlds of performance, recording and music education.

Sergei Rachmaninov (Russia, 1873-1943) Regarded as one of the greatest pianists of the twentieth century, Rachmaninov had legendary technical facilities and rhythmic drive, and his large hands were able to cover the interval of a thirteenth on the keyboard. Today his piano music is amongst the most well-loved and widely-performed in the standard repertoire, yet in the 1950s the Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians dismissed it as “monotonous in texture…..consist[ing] of mainly of artificial and gushing tunes….”. He was composing at a time when music was undergoing huge sea-changes (atonality and the development of the 12-note tone row, for example), yet he remained true to his own compositional vision and his music is unashamedly Romantic, full of sweeping melodies and rich textures. Even in his miniatures (the Preludes, Moments Musicaux, Etudes-Tableaux) his music displays his understanding of all the elements of music, and seems to express the vastness of the Russian landscape. It has a visceral, deeply honest quality which makes it incredibly rewarding to play. His own playing style was extremely clean and precise, with a luminous cantabile tone.

Rachmaninov plays Rachmaninov – Prelude in G Minor

Marguerite Long (France, 1874-1966) Regarded as France’s foremost woman pianist during the first half of the twentieth century, Marguerite Long was taught initially by her sister. In 1889, even before completing her studies at the Paris Conservatoire, Long won first prize and immediately started forging an international career as soloist and teacher. She was particularly devoted to performing music by her fellow compatriots Fauré, Debussy, Satie, Roger-Ducasse, Ravel, Milhaud, and Poulenc. She premiered Ravel’s Piano Concerto in G which was dedicated to her, and she later wrote a volume of memoirs on Ravel which contains detailed advice on the interpretation and performance of his piano works. She was one of the last pianists to study with Debussy, though at first she resisted playing his music, claiming its style was too enigmatic. A respected teacher herself, she developed her own method of mastering the technique jeu perle, typical of the French piano style in which each note is crisp and pure like a pearl in a string.

Long plays Milhaud
Alfama, from L’Automne, Op. 115, No. 2 (1932)

Alfred CortotCredit: http://www.ecolenormalecortot.com/

Alfred Cortot
Credit: http://www.ecolenormalecortot.com/

Alfred Cortot (Switzerland, 1877-1962). Cortot is particularly notable for his combination of interpretative freedom (sometimes considered eccentric by today’s standards) and deep insight into the composer’s intentions. He is noted for his eloquent phrasing, unaffected rhythmic freedom, and beautiful quality of sound, undoubtedly helped by the pianos of his day. Always sensitive to the mercurial moods of Schumann or Chopin’s expansive lyricism, Cortot seems at one with the composer. He is sometimes described unfairly as the pianist who played lots of wrong notes, but he never allowed striving for absolute accuracy to distract him from communicating the pictures, narratives and emotional content of the music. His editions of the works of Chopin, Schumann and Debussy are significant for their inclusion of detailed commentary on technical problems and interpretative issues, which provide pianists of today with important information on performance traditions. His writings contained not only technical suggestions and exercises, but also imaginative thoughts on what was happening in the music, literary references and other insights, suggesting that the pianist need not confine his or her study simply to the notes on the score. “Cortot helped me realise how free you can be.” (Angela Hewitt)

Cortot plays Chopin
Ballade No. 1 in G Minor, Op. 23

Clara HaskilCredit: http://www.bach-cantatas.com/

Clara Haskil
Credit: http://www.bach-cantatas.com/

Clara Haskil (Romania, 1895-1960) Dinu Lipatti described her playing as “the sum of perfection on earth”, Tatyana Nikoleyeva burst into tears when she first heard her. Clara Haskil’s playing was special for its purity of tone and phrasing that may have been the result of her skill as a violinist. Other hallmarks of her style were delicacy, a relaxed yet emphatic authority and sensitive interpretations. Her musical talent was evident in early childhood and she gave her first public performance at the age of 10, later graduating from the Paris Conservatoire at 15 with the Premier Prix. Concert tours around Europe followed but her career was halted abruptly in 1913 when she was fitted with a plaster cast to prevent scoliosis (curvature) of the spine. Her entire life was subsequently beset by illness. This, combined with stage fright, which emerged in 1920, kept her from critical or financial success, and she spent much of her life in penury. It was only after the Second World War that she began to receive recognition for her performances during a series of concerts in the Netherlands. Her repertoire, largely comprising music from the Romantic period, belied her physical weaknesses. Her life is a unique testimony to the fragility of artist, and in recognition of her musical legacy, the Clara Haskil International Festival was established in 1965.

Haskil plays Schumann
Kinderszenen (Scenes of Childhood), Op. 15

Sviatoslav Richter (Russia, 1915-1997). Richter seemed to be superhuman, possessed of a formidable technique, and huge hands, which enabled him to play almost anything and the imagination to create vivid colours and nuances. Fearsomely intellectual, he chose to perform pieces exactly the way composers had written them, with vertiginous speed and precision. He had no formal training as a pianist until he entered the Moscow Conservatory in 1922 where he studied under Heinrich Neuhaus, who said of him “[he] treated each composition like a vast landscape, which he surveyed from great height with the vision of an eagle, taking in the whole and all the details at the same time. He played like no one I had ever heard, and there was nothing I could teach him.” He never rested on the laurels of his success and continued to expand his repertoire throughout his life. His concerts, often in near darkness, were intense, meditative, almost religious experiences for the listener, while his performances of the late sonatas of Beethoven and Schubert are profound and philosophical.

Richter plays Beethoven
Piano Sonata no. 32, op. 111

Alfred BrendelCredit: http://i.telegraph.co.uk/

Alfred Brendel
Credit: http://i.telegraph.co.uk/

Alfred Brendel (Austria, 1931-). Brendel is a highly intellectual pianist, known for his thoughtful and masterly performances and recordings of the works of Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert, Brahms and Liszt, many of which have become benchmarks in the piano world. He shares Richter’s view that the pianist should be responsible to the piece and display fidelity to the score. Largely self-taught, he feels teachers can be “too influential” and cites listening to other pianists, conductors and singers as important learning tools for the pianist. Perhaps as a reflection of this, he has always been very selective about whom he mentors. Amongst his few protégés are Imogen Cooper (UK), Till Fellner (Austria) and Paul Lewis (UK). A noted writer and public speaker, he is one of the indisputable authorities and sharpest observers of musical life today.

Brendel plays Haydn
Piano Sonata nº 59 in E flat, Hob. XVI:49

Glenn Gould (Canada, 1932-82) It is perhaps a mark of Gould’s artistic status, and the enduring power of J S Bach’s music, that his recording of the first Prelude and Fugue from Bach’s Well-Tempered Clavier was included on the Voyager spacecraft. His two recordings of the Goldberg Variations are regarded by many as the benchmarks for this work. He was able to create a remarkable resonance through the care with which he placed each note, and he displayed a deep understanding of Bach’s counterpoint as well as creating a clear narrative line through the whole piece.

A noted eccentric and hypochondriac – he wore overcoat, gloves, scarf and hat whatever the weather, refused to shake hands with people in case it damaged his own hands, and took copious amounts of pills for real and imagined ailments – he retired from performing in 1964 when he was only 31, regarding public concerts as an anachronism and the audience as innately hostile. Instead he devoted himself entirely to recording. He felt the opportunity to manipulate the tape was part of the creative process and enjoyed having total artistic control over the recording. In many ways, he was ahead of his time and would probably have been fascinated by the ability afforded by today’s technology to manipulate and minutely adjust recordings as well as the opportunity to share music and create personalised playlists via streaming services such as Spotify.

Gould plays Bach
The WellTempered Clavier

Martha Argerich (Argentina, 1941-). The phenomenal talent of Martha Argerich first came to worldwide attention in 1964 when she won the International Chopin Piano Competition at the age of 24. Today her reputation is such that she can sell out the biggest venues in a matter of moments. She combines astonishing technical prowess with a fierce intellect and an unaffected interpretation which brings great naturalness to her performances: when she plays she appears to embody the music rather than simply interpret it. She made her debut at the age of eight in Buenos Aires and by the time she was 16 she was winning competitions. She has a broad and varied repertoire and is a noted collaborator with other great artists such as Daniel Barenboim, violinist Gidon Kremer, cellist Mischa Maisky, and conductor Charles Dutoit (to whom she was briefly married). She is one of the more enigmatic personalities on the international piano circuit, due in part to her reclusive shunning of the press, and, haunted by her insecurities, can be an erratic performer, famously prone to canceling concerts at the last minute which only adds to her mystique.

Argerich plays Prokofiev
Toccata in D Minor, Op. 11

Maria João Pires (Portugal, 1944-) Her performances and recordings of Mozart and Schubert in particular are cherished and celebrated for their exquisite intimacy, lucid elegance and stylistic refinement, yet Maria João Pires is a modest and self-effacing pianist. She emphasises the spiritual element of the music she performs, searching for hidden meanings and revealing a remarkable reverence, most evident in her performances of Mozart, regarding herself as a channel for the composer’s ideas. Her emotional intensity is revealed in great variety of tone, touch and expression, ranging from gossamer lightness to an imposing monumentality. A performer who is not keen on the concept of the “professional concert pianist”, and who shuns the limelight, she has always insisted on doing things her way, preferring to devote much of her time to encouraging and supporting young artists through her Partitura Project at the Queen Elisabeth Music Chapel in Belgium, which seeks to thwart the effects of the “star system” prevalent in many conservatoires and international music competitions by encouraging reciprocal listening and support between generations.

Pires plays Mozart
Piano Sonata No. 11 in A Major, K. 331

Stephen Hough (England, 1961 – ) Stephen Hough is a musical polymath. In addition to his distinguished performing career, he is an acclaimed composer, in the tradition of the great composer-pianists Liszt and Rachmaninov. He is also a noted writer on music, contemporary culture, philosophy and religion, and his wide-ranging interests allow him to see beyond the music to create perceptive and deeply thoughtful performances. In addition to highly-praised performances of core repertoire, he has an interest in contemporary and neglected nineteenth-century piano music. Like Rachmaninov before him, he boasts scintillating technique, a sparkling sound, and clarity of line, and his playing integrates his broad outlook, vivid imagination and profound intelligence.

Hough plays Hough
Piano Sonata, “Broken Branches”

Related Posts:

More in Blog:

Latest Articles:

3 Comments

    1. Your list is more notable for the pianists it excludes, rather the ones that are included. Regardless whether or not the latter group was chosen by dint of ignorance or personal preference, it is probably in your best interest to title your selection as the pianists that you particularly like, without referring to comparative greatness.

    2. Perahia at his last recital at Carnegie hall in 2017 has forgotten half of the notes …. let him go quietly to a retirement home in Florida or Israel

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *